Fixing fieldstone foundation issues on old Michigan basements is about 90% of our work for about 4 months out of the year. We have a lot of fieldstone basements and crawlspaces in Michigan and they need some maintenance from time to time. I wanted to share some of the most common things we run into when inspecting stone foundations for repair. Below is a photograph of a fieldstone foundation wall that has some obvious issues:

fieldstone foundation issues

You can see most of the mortar joints have crumbled away and some are missing altogether, this is actually pretty common. This wall looks like it is leaning pretty badly in the photo, but it actually wasn’t. If it were, addressing that type fieldstone foundation issue would be for another post all together.

Tuckpointing Is The Most Common Fieldstone Foundation Issue in Basements.

I would say 75% of the fieldstone foundation issues we see are mostly tuckpointing. In other words 7-8 out of ten fieldstone foundations we inspect are mostly just in need of tuckpointing. There are almost always an area or two that need some minor repair. Areas around windows or duct work pass throughs were a stone or two has come loose or fallen from the wall. The other 25% of he projects (1-2 out of ten) require more extensive work.

How we Fix Fieldstone Foundation Issues

Usually, like I mentioned above, the mortar joints between the rocks or stones will need to be given some attention. That attention in this case is tuckpointing. Here is a framework we use for evaluating fieldstone foundation issues:

  • Is the wall safe to be and work around?
  • Are the walls generally where they should be? Are they leaning, bowing, or shifted?
  • Have the joints crumbled away and mostly missing?
  • Are the mortar joints intact but loose and crumbling, are they failing?
  • Is this fieldstone foundation a good candidate for tuckpointing?

Usually the outcome after going thru this checklist I use to evaluate fieldstone foundation issues is that the walls are good candidates for tuckpointing. I go over how we tuckpoint stone basement walls in another article and won’t go into that here. There is almost always some tuckpointing involved in dealing with fieldstone foundation issues, especially in basements.

Wall Collapses are a common Fieldstone Foundation Issue

Often there are other concerns as well. Many times customers have us update the windows in their old Michigan basements. We do a lot of crawlspace repair and it seems like most often the collapses occur in the fieldstone crawlspaces. It’s pretty common for the fieldstone crawl space foundations to almost be dry stacked on the inside portion of the wall. There is mortar there but it was very thin to begin with and was often un-tooled and unsealed. For this reason they don’t hold up as well as the fieldstone basement walls. Fieldstone wall collapses are less of an issue that they appear to be. They are usually localized and aren’t really that difficult to repair. I think I will follow up with another article on fixing fieldstone wall collapses. I have some pretty cool photos I need to find.

Most of our winter work is stone basement repair service projects. Most of those being stone basements with at least one crawl space area attached to the original stone foundation. We try to save these stone wall repair projects for winter mainly because the weather limits the outside work we can do.

Wintertime Stone Basement Repair

January thru March, for our company, is pretty much spent in dingy lit stone basements across the state of Michigan. The winter months are perfect for doing those interior repairs and restorations on stone foundations. For the month of January we will most be in the Ann Arbor area doing 4 tuckpointing projects. The one project has the normal crumbling mortar in the basement walls , so we will go in and remove all the loose surface mortar, fix any spots where the joints are missing altogether, then spend a couple days tuckpointing the walls.

The other three are similar with some areas that need the stone foundation wall rebuilt between a basement area and a crawl space area. One of them is mainly a stone crawl space repair project and will take a few days. There’s always a bit a mix but this basically summarizes the winter stone basement repair services we find ourselves doing.

Stone Basement Repair Services

Over the years of fixing stone basements a few commonly recurring issues have essentially become the main services we offer our customers. Our stone basement repair services include:

  • Tuckpointing
  • Spot Repairs
  • Apply Foundation Coating

Tuck pointing is probably where we spend the majority of our time on stone basement projects. Depending on the current state of the mortar joints size of the basement, typical tuckpointing projects usually fall in the range of 2-4 days and fall in the price range of $3,500-$6,500 dollars.

Spot repairs are what we basically call problem areas in the foundation. Sometime HVAC contractors might dismantle parts of the stone foundation. Sometimes a pipe or electrical line is installed through the wall and now the stone wall is coming apart. Spot repairs are common and usually not to big of a deal. They are usually repaired within a few hours and don’t cost much.

Applying foundation coating is a process we often do after spot repairs and tuckpointing is complete throughout a stone basement. Usually when we work on a stone foundation some of the existing joints are still structurally sound and don’t need replaced. The foundation coating we use is a cementitious coating and offers a good preservation value. Its breathable, so it wont delaminate, and it provides a much cleaner wall and it just looks better.

Stone foundation repair, mainly tuck pointing, makes up about 90% or our work during the winter in Michigan. Around eight years ago I began strategically offering a significant discount on tuck jointing projects when our customers are willing to schedule them in the winter months. Its been a win-win all the way around. We are busy all winter long and most of our tuck pointing is interior.

We focus on Michigan stone basement tuck pointing projects during the winter months as the temperatures makes exterior work, like tuck pointing barns, pretty difficult or even impossible without weather protection. I wanted to share some before and after pictures, which would be a lot easier if I would actually take before and after pictures of tuck pointing projects. But I do have a few.

Stone Tuck Pointing Projects

Tuck pointing projects are pretty straight forward with the only real variable being the condition of the existing mortar joints. Usually, if the foundation or wall is made of stone, there are often spot repairs that need to be done to fix loose or fallen stone. Probably half of the the interior stone wall tuck pointing projects we do are strictly tuckpointing, no repairs needed at all. Below I’m going to show some before and after photos of some recent projects we did tuck pointing work on.

Before Tuck Pointing A Stone and Brick Foundation

This was a project we did in Cork town right near downtown Detroit Michigan. This is one of the oldest standing residential structures in the area, most were destroyed in a massive fire. It was a really cool project.

After Tuck Pointing Stone Wall

This particular foundation had a 4′ stone wall with a triple thick red brick wall on that. The red brick wall went all the way up to the top of the structure, which is now a home. I suspect it was built for commercial purposes initially, based on the construction. Once we tuck pointed the stone portion, we used a slightly different tuck pointing mix and also re pointed the brick walls. The brick walls were missing a significant amount of mortar joints and much of them were loose. We went in and removed or ground out poor joints where needed, using a 4″ grinder with a diamond tuck pointing blade. The we tuck pointed new joints back in.

Stone Basement Tuck Pointing

Residential Stone basement tuck pointing makes up a lion’s share of out winter work here in Michigan. We do a lot of new field stone wall construction, decorative concrete design projects, and other exterior projects that require decent weather and warmer temperatures.

Tuck Pointing done on a Michigan Basement

Tuck Pointing Stone Structures To Restore and Preserve

Below is part of a massive project we did on the west side of the state, over by Lake Michigan. We worked on this project for a month or so in the spring and the another month or two in the fall. We did that for a couple years actually. There were several smaller projects, with the one pictured below being the largest of the projects we completed. This structure need a significant amount of tuck pointing and repairs, so we ended up doing a more cosmetic tuck pointing process on the entire structure. Literally every single joint was either removed and replaced, tuck pointed or received a thin mortar tuck pointing to make it all match.

Tuck Pointing As a Beautification Project

This picture, to me, really shows the real issue with tuck pointing. Its not rocket science, it just really tedious. I’ll write another post at some point that lays out how to tuck point, but essentially its all pretty straight forward. If you don’t have the skill set or the experience, it just takes a long time. A project that takes us a few days to tuck point would take a home owner weeks or months, no exaggeration.

Why Is Tuck Pointing Important?

Most of our work is initiated by a home owner or building manager who can see that their stone walls are shedding mortar along the floor. Often times there are significant areas where the mortar joints between the stone are missing altogether. Over time the mortar, through drying out, will fail. Many of the tuck pointing projects we do on old stone basements were built when lime mortar was the material used to lay the stone. Tuck pointing is important and adds a lot of long term value to stone basements, stone walls, and other stone, block or brick foundations.

5 Reasons Tuck Pointing is Important

  • Tuck pointing maintains stability of the stone wall
  • Tuck pointing keeps ground water from entering from the exterior
  • Tuckpointing helps to keep critters out of the wall
  • Tuckpointing makes for a much cleaner basement
  • Tuck pointing helps to identify any shifts in a stone foundation wall in the future

These are some of the more significant reasons tuck pointing is important. The first point about it maintaining stability of the wall is a the most important from a cost perspective. It cost much much more to rebuild a wall collapse than it does to go through do spot repairs and tuck pointing.

Often times historic buildings were made with stone foundations and tuck pointing is an integral part of maintaining these structures so we can carry them into the future. We are fortunate to have many associations in America and in Michigan that work to carry on historical preservation and restoration. Michigan Barn Preservation Network is one of these associations that work to help preserve those big red barns we have in Michigan. They are a joy to work on and tuck pointing is an unobtrusive way to maintain the structural integrity of these structures.